8 Investment Strategy Mistakes to Avoid
Key Takeaways
- Investor behavior matters. Emotional decisions can cause investors to earn less than the investments they own.
- Diversification requires balance. Owning too many overlapping strategies or concentrating too much wealth in a few investments can create unnecessary risks.
- Avoid letting emotions drive your decisions. Euphoria, panic, speculation, and anchoring can interfere with your long-term investment strategy.
- Your portfolio should support your life. Focus on total return, managing risk, and funding your future spending needs rather than chasing performance.
- Past mistakes don't have to define your future. Recognizing unhelpful investment behaviors is the first step toward making better decisions.
Have You Forgiven Yourself for Past Mistakes?
When was the last time you truly forgave someone?
I'm talking about a time when someone did wrong to you with no explanation, leaving you bewildered as to why you were treated that way. You had no real recourse except to pick yourself up and move on. But before you could truly do that, you had to forgive that person.
It was unfair, it was unjust, and it was simply not right to think that you, who had been wronged, now had to forgive someone who had shown no remorse, no concern, and certainly no effort to get you back on your feet.
I know I'm asking you to dig up a bad memory, but I don't want you to dwell on the bad. Instead, think about how you felt when you finally forgave them.
The burden of carrying the wrongdoing, which may have been worse than the actual event itself, finally lifted. You could move on.
Now, think about a time when you did wrong by you.
Have you forgiven yourself for that?
If you have, I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that you learned a lot from whatever decision was poorly made. And I'll bet you don't let it happen again.
Let me introduce you to an area where you may have done yourself wrong in the past but have yet to even realize it.
The BIG investment mistakes.
Why Investors Underperform Their Investments
First, I'd like to share why I think you, and just about everyone else, have fallen victim to one of these mistakes in the past.
DALBAR, a market research firm, publishes its annual Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior study, examining how investors perform compared with market benchmarks.
At first, the idea that investors could underperform their investments may seem nonsensical.
But the difference becomes clearer when we look at how money flows into and out of investments, and when those transactions occur.
For example, imagine a mutual fund that earns a strong return over several years. If investors put most of their money into that fund after its biggest gains, their personal returns may be much lower than the fund's reported performance.
Likewise, investors who sell after a market decline may lock in losses and miss a subsequent recovery.
The problem isn't necessarily the investment. It's when investors decide to buy or sell.
DALBAR's research has repeatedly highlighted the importance of investor behavior and the potential performance gap between investors and market benchmarks.
While the size of that gap changes from year to year, the lesson remains relevant: Chasing recent winners and abandoning investments during downturns can undermine long-term results.
We, as an investing community trying to fund our life's expenses with an investment portfolio, sometimes get in our own way.
And that brings us to the eight BIG mistakes.
Eight BIG Investment Mistakes That Tempt Us All
I believe there are at least eight BIG mistakes we're tempted to make at various times.
We're not necessarily susceptible to all of them at once. But as we look back over our investing history, we may recognize ourselves in more than one.
1. Over-Diversification
This happens when we find ourselves owning several different investment strategies.
All of these strategies probably made sense to us at one point. However, over time, they've combined into one big, strange Frankenstein portfolio.
Perhaps we started with five core funds. Then we read an article or had a conversation that convinced us to add a specialty fund or two.
We didn't track or adjust these holdings over time. When another investment tip came along, we found the cash and added another piece to our not-so-fitting puzzle.
Ultimately, this leaves us not really knowing what we own.
We may have duplicate holdings, overlapping investment exposures, and perhaps even fees on top of fees across our portfolio.
Ironically, owning more funds doesn't necessarily mean we're better diversified.
If several funds own many of the same companies, we may have created unintended concentrations.
And because each strategy seemed like a good idea when we bought it, we may feel trapped. We don't want to adjust any of our mini strategies for fear that their time has finally come.
The goal isn't to own as many investments as possible. It's to own a thoughtfully diversified portfolio where every investment serves a purpose.
2. Under-Diversification
This one is really tough because it feels logical but can end up hurting us.
It stems from our tendency to keep narrowing our investment strategy by sticking with "what's working."
The problem is that what works today may not work tomorrow.
And if we've eventually narrowed our portfolio down to a single investment idea, watch out!
In 1999, I heard plenty of people say they were diversified because they owned technology, telecommunications, and dot-com companies.
We all know how that ended.
I've also heard people say they're diversified because they own two or three rental properties.
In the Bay Area.
In the same price range.
Sometimes even in the same neighborhood.
Eek!
Those properties may be separate investments, but they share many of the same risks.
True diversification means spreading our wealth across investments that don't all depend on the same companies, industries, economic conditions, or geographic markets.
Diversification doesn't eliminate risk, but it helps reduce our dependence on any single investment or outcome.
3. Euphoria
You can also call this one "greed" if you'd like.
Euphoria happens when rising investment prices convince us that the risk of a decline is getting lower.
It often appears when people feel they're "missing out" and want to be sure they're earning at least as high a return as their neighbor.
The longer an investment rises, the easier it becomes to believe that the good times will continue indefinitely.
But rising prices don't make an investment immune to risk.
In fact, the temptation to abandon a disciplined investment strategy can become particularly strong when everyone around us seems to be making money.
We may start taking risks we would never have considered when markets were less exciting.
The danger isn't feeling optimistic about the future. It's allowing that optimism to override our investment discipline.
4. Panic
Just like the other mistakes, panic has a way of rationalizing itself.
It doesn't necessarily feel irrational at the time.
Instead, it comes with phrases like:
- "I have to get out of the markets until the election is over."
- "I'll invest again when we get the deficit under control."
- "I'm waiting until inflation settles down."
- "I need to see how the economy handles the next crisis."
There's always a reason, and it's usually some crisis being discussed in the news.
Don't get me wrong. There are plenty of things we should be concerned about.
But many of them are things we can't actually control.
It's okay to feel fear and even panic. It's another thing entirely to risk your life's spending plan based on those feelings alone.
A sound investment strategy should already account for the fact that markets will experience uncertainty, downturns, and unexpected events.
The challenge is sticking with that strategy when fear makes doing so uncomfortable.
5. Speculating Instead of Investing
In a previous blog, we discussed what makes an investment different from speculation.
Speculation is generally a bet on future price movements rather than the long-term value an investment can produce.
It often involves buying something primarily because we believe someone else will pay more for it later.
And when we're following a rapidly rising price trend, we may end up buying high.
We can speculate for fun, just like buying a lottery ticket.
But we don't bet our family's financial success on speculation.
Investing should be about building wealth over time to support our future spending needs, not guessing which investment will be the next big winner.
6. Investing for Yield Instead of Total Return
Pretend for a minute that you own a well, and you depend on that well to gather water for your survival.
Does it really matter if the water comes from snowfall or rain?
Investments earn their way in two primary ways:
- Income: Dividends or interest paid by the investment.
- Growth: An increase in the investment's value over time.
Together, these make up an investment's total return.
Getting too focused on either income or growth can cause us to miss the bigger picture.
For example, an investment with a high dividend yield isn't necessarily a better investment if its underlying value is declining.
Likewise, an investment that grows in value but produces little income may still play an important role in funding future expenses.
What matters is the total value our investments can provide over time, balanced against the risks we're taking.
After all, we're investing to fund our planned expenses, not to win a contest over which type of return is better.
Focus on the total return of your portfolio and how it supports your lifetime spending plan.
7. Letting Your Cost Basis Determine Your Portfolio
Technically, this is called anchoring.
It happens when we're unwilling to sell an investment because of the price we paid for it in the past.
For example, perhaps you received stock awards from your employer, and those shares have declined in value since they vested.
Now you don't want to sell them at a "loss."
Or maybe you inherited an investment whose value has fallen since you received it.
In either case, the price associated with a past transaction becomes the deciding factor in whether you continue holding the investment.
The BIG mistake occurs when these investments represent a large portion of your wealth, leaving you under-diversified.
Instead of asking whether an investment has recovered to a particular price, we should ask:
"If I had this money in cash today, would I choose to buy this investment?"
If the answer is no, it's worth reconsidering why we continue to own it.
Of course, taxes and transaction costs matter. Selling an appreciated investment can create capital gains taxes, and the tax treatment of inherited assets and stock awards can vary.
Those considerations should be part of the decision, but they shouldn't automatically outweigh the risk of holding a concentrated position.
Our investment strategy should reflect where we want to go, not simply what we paid in the past.
8. Leverage
Often tied to great overconfidence in the markets, leverage happens when we borrow money to invest more in our portfolio.
It's a particularly seductive mistake because, in some ways, it makes sense.
If you could borrow at 4% and invest in stocks that earn 6%, shouldn't you do this as much as possible?
No, and here's why.
Stocks don't go up in a straight line at 6% per year.
They experience volatility, sometimes substantial volatility.
A sharp market decline can dramatically reduce the value of a leveraged portfolio while leaving the debt outstanding.
In some cases, investors may even be forced to sell investments during a downturn to meet lending requirements.
More to the point, the temptation to bail out of an investment strategy that "isn't working" can become overwhelming when borrowed money magnifies the losses.
Here on planet Earth, I don't know many people who would want to withstand that experience.
At Best Financial Life, we don't recommend borrowing specifically to invest in the stock market.
The additional potential return simply isn't worth jeopardizing the financial plan we've worked so hard to build.
What Gets in the Way of Better Investment Decisions?
It's obvious.
We do.
As humans, we have a tendency to want to control the things around us.
But not everything can be controlled.
On top of that, we don't want to feel like we're missing out or that our neighbors are doing something better than we are.
We want to feel respected and be seen as savvy, especially when it comes to our money.
It's this emotional roller coaster that we all must ride that drives us to make the mistakes above, and many more.
Besides, we often feel like we have no help.
We don't always speak openly about our money challenges or financial decisions.
We may not want to share the whole picture with friends, family, or even our spouses.
We want to be seen as having everything under control.
Even when we don't.
Here's the Good News: You Can Learn From Your Mistakes
You can forgive yourself for past investment mistakes and move forward with confidence.
In fact, the field of behavioral economics has spent decades studying how human psychology influences financial decisions.
Researchers have identified many of the tendencies we've discussed, including loss aversion, overconfidence, anchoring, and herd behavior.
The growing awareness of these behaviors makes it easier to recognize that our investment mistakes aren't necessarily personal failings.
They're often the result of being human.
And sharing our fears out loud is a great first step toward addressing them.
Sometimes the best course of action is to make a thoughtful adjustment.
Other times, the best decision is to do nothing at all.
Additionally, and I admit this is a shameless plug, a good financial planner who's experienced in helping clients manage the behavioral challenges of investing can be a tremendous asset to your lifetime spending plan.
A well-designed investment strategy isn't just about selecting investments.
It's about building a plan you can understand, trust, and stick with through the inevitable ups and downs of the market.
What Areas of Your Investment Strategy Do You Need Help With?
I'd love to hear your thoughts. Send me a direct email at Joe@BestFinLife.com.
Ready to explore a simpler investment strategy with more value?
If you're ready to move forward with greater confidence in your financial life, schedule a complimentary virtual conversation here.
Related Articles
